IELTSライティング Task 2: バンド5.5 エッセイサンプル — 政府
エッセイ問題
"Rich countries often give money to poorer countries, but it does not solve poverty. Therefore, developed countries should give other types of help to the poor countries rather than financial aid. To what extent do you agree or disagree?"
提出されたエッセイ
ハイライトされたテキストをクリックして提案を表示
Human beings are facing many challenges nowadays. Poverty is always an critical topic among countries, especially the poverty in developing countries. Developed countries frequently offer financial support to poor countries but the poverty still exist. Experts are arguing that developed countries should consider other solutions to help solve the poverty issue. I believe this is a much better direction compare to money support only.
Money is essential to many factors like food, contruction and hospital. With money provided by developed countries, govenment can improve the inforstructure, supporting poor family with food, building more houses for the poor people, builing more schools to support children's education, which is critical for people to get out of poverty.
But money cannot solve everything. The poverty caused by many reasons like lacking of resource and experienced governor. None of them could be solved by simply offering money to the goverment. Besides, money could cause a bad habit to the governor, they may reply on the financial support too much. If the financial support ended someday, which could happen anytime in the current circurmestance, it will cause big trouble again.
Devevloped countries should focus on a sophicated solution instead of just providing money. For example, they can help poor countries to build manufacturing industry, and give certain subsides for the customer who buy directly from them. Developed countries also can send experienced instructor to help governer in poor countries build a better government system to improve the efficiency of governance, authority of justice, to make sure company feel safe to invest in these developing counties, which could have a long term benifit for the people there.
Overall, I am agree that money could help to solve the poverty but without other support from different functions, it may not the best solution for poverty.
Nomad English 評価
タスク達成度
6.5
一貫性と結束性
5.5
語彙力
5
文法の幅と正確性
5
試験官フィードバック
このエッセイはトピックに取り組み、財政援助と代替支援方法の両方について関連するアイデアで明確な立場を示しています。構造は論理的で、導入、本文段落、結論があります。しかし、全体を通して頻出するスペルミス（「contruction」「inforstructure」「circurmestance」「sophicated」など）が大きく評価を下げています。冠詞の誤用、主語と動詞の不一致、前置詞の欠落など、文法的な誤りも頻繁に見られます。
バンド9 モデル回答
同じ問題に対するバンド9の模範回答：
Poverty remains one of the most critical issues facing developing nations, and the debate over how wealthy countries can most effectively provide assistance is both timely and important. While financial aid serves a purpose, I believe that developed nations should adopt a more comprehensive approach that prioritises sustainable development strategies over direct monetary support.
Admittedly, financial assistance plays a valuable role in addressing the immediate needs of impoverished countries. Funding can be allocated to essential services such as food distribution, housing construction, hospital development, and educational infrastructure. These investments in basic provision are necessary to meet urgent humanitarian needs and can provide a foundation upon which longer-term development initiatives may be built.
However, financial aid alone cannot address the root causes of poverty. Many developing nations suffer from a lack of natural resources, institutional expertise, and effective governance — problems that cannot be resolved simply by transferring funds. Moreover, an over-reliance on external financial support can create a culture of dependency, leaving recipient nations vulnerable should such aid be reduced or withdrawn due to changing economic or political circumstances in donor countries.
A more effective strategy would involve developed countries providing holistic, multifaceted support. This could include helping poorer nations establish manufacturing industries and offering trade incentives that grant direct market access. Equally important is the deployment of experienced advisors to assist governments in building robust institutional frameworks — improving administrative efficiency, strengthening the rule of law, and creating an environment conducive to foreign investment. Such measures would generate long-term, self-sustaining economic benefits for the populations concerned.
In conclusion, while financial aid has a role in alleviating the most acute symptoms of poverty, it is insufficient as a standalone solution. Developed countries should complement monetary assistance with comprehensive support encompassing infrastructure development, institutional reform, and economic empowerment to achieve meaningful and lasting change.
あなたのエッセイも即座にフィードバック
AI評価システムがIELTSライティングを数秒で採点 — 上記のような詳細な添削付き。
無料で試す